Dr Hany El Banna is the president of The Humanitarian Forum, as well as the founder of Islamic Relief, Muslim Charities Forum, Zakat House and the International HIV Fund. He has visited the world's poorest and most vulnerable countries on behalf of these organisations and works tirelessly for those in need. On this blog you can find his own views on life and development.
Tuesday, 18 May 2010
The Unanswered Questions
Once upon a time, the world woke up to find a crisis which I call the ‘OFF’ crisis: a crisis of Oil, Food and Fuel. These three components have shaken the whole world, particularly the silent majority of the poor and the most marginalised, who don’t suffer from the loss of the equity value, but rather from every cent added to their daily living expenses.
We are still witnessing appalling catastrophes in DRC and Somalia, and nobody claims to have the solution; the answers to the question of why the gap between the rich and poor has become a chasm. Is this the result of free market economy? Global economy? Transnational and multinational businesses? Why should we have more poor when we are becoming richer?
What is fuelling the flames of the world’s conflicts? Is it war lords and arms manufacturers? Or is it the international community? Who’s paying for the cost of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq? Is it the Afghani and Iraqi people? The neighbouring countries and the region? Or is it the countries in the west – the taxpayers who are funding the defence budgets?
Is the solution to ideological, theological and cultural problems military action or security measures? What solution can we find on our humanitarian menu?
Many humanitarians adopt a ‘do no harm’ policy – but this can often mean inaction in the face of crisis. Does a ‘do no harm’ policy actually cause harm? Does it mean we fail to stop agressors and wrongdoers through not interfering? Indeed, should a ‘do no harm’ policy call our humanitarian neutrality and impartiality into question?
Who is responsible for the world now? Who is governing the world? And are the policies and actions of global government bodies upholding the rights of humanity and humanitarian principles or degrading them? Are our governments driven by the economy or by the needs of their people? We talk about respect, equality and fairness, but we need to believe in them, even if it means a material loss to ourselves.
Why is there so much conflict between different faiths and belief systems? Aren’t we ultimately all striving for the same goals? Can’t we make space for each others’ faith and beliefs? Are we trying to create a new global system to replace the existing one, or are we interested only in our own desires? The most precious being is the human being who is losing his or her life – millions every day. Who amongst us is responsible for the daily loss of innocent life?
HIV/AIDS has become not just a medical problem, but a social issue too. Is our policy just to live with it? Or to eradicate it, and how can we protect our children from contracting it?
What are the real causes of climate change? Is it our ignorance or our partners who share the planet – birds, animals, trees etc? Or is it the industrial drive which only serves its own interests?
Nobody knows how many billions or trillions of dollars are spent on curbing the newly created monster that is terrorism, but what is becoming all too clear is that we cannot meet the millennium development goals because we haven’t enough resources. But who’s deciding where resources are spent?
Are we fuelling conflict or are we diminishing its fire? What is our role as individuals leading governments and global institutions, when the plethora of conflicts is on the rise by the second? Can we really call natural disasters by that name, or are they at least to some degree man made? When it rains, are we a part of the flood, the tsunami, the hurricane? We need to redefine what we mean by natural disaster, by climate change, by global warming, and pollution. What are the root causes and where will it take us?
I don’t believe God makes people suffer. I believe that we need to take responsibility for our actions and inaction, and for the consequences: for conflict, for illness and hunger, for violence against women and abused and abandoned children. At the very beginning of the new millennium, we should have the courage to find real answers to these questions instead of fighting the fires that we ourselves have lit.
There are too many ‘why’s, ‘how’s ‘who’s. But while we’re looking at all these questions, we don’t pinpoint the real solutions– we need a champion who will say ‘I will’ or ‘we will’.
Are our Millenium Development Goals complete, fulfilling the needs, or do they need to be revised? Or is it our other goals which need revision: those more self-interested goals which do not look out into the world, but can’t see past our own advancement?
My last question is one that keeps many of us awake at night. What is the value of our life if we fail to value the lives of others? Valuing human life cannot be a passive activity. I wish one day that our subconscious will be more aware that ‘do no harm’ can be very harmful. ‘Do nothing’ does not reflect neutrality, but rather indifference to suffering and putting our interests in the security of the few before the survival of many. Humanity does not need a new religion or a new messiah, but it does need new believers in humanity. Let us all believe together in shared common humanitarian values that can save all of us before it’s too late for us and our children.
Thursday, 6 May 2010
The biggest challenge: preserving issues or serving interests?
In a year or two the group will start thinking about developing the project, to make it more organised and structured. The group will collectively decide to change the project into an organisation, because the capacity of the organisation is now wider than the scope of the project that the organisation is serving. In the following years the group will think again and then again about institutionalising their organisation and it will change from a small community based enterprise to a national organisation.
To move from the inception of the idea to the making of the institution, we have to go through a bottleneck. And the most difficult challenge to overcome is to continue to serve the idea – to remember the issue and to preserve our community product, rather than to serve the organisation, its structure and quite often the individuals who run it.
If the organisation fails to focus on the original idea as it grows, it will fail in its objective and will suffer a downfall. This is the problem we face nowadays with political parties, groups, movements and structured organisations, who quite often forget the great idea which led to their existence and instead begin to focus on the group, the party, or individual interests. It is the big challenge facing all of us at times of election or change because all these parties’ interests are not compatible. They don’t compliment each other, but rather each would like to uproot the others, forgetting that the resources they have are national, communal resources, and each community needs to see the resources working.
Unfortunately I have seen this happening not only in political parties, but also inside humanitarian organisations which still claim to champion humanity. But if we are really looking to preserve and grow our civilisation, we have to ensure our organisations and institutions keep serving humanity by being true to their ideals. Only then can they develop it and change it into ideology and global community culture. This won’t happen if they are serving the organisations’ interests.
I hope this will be – for me as well as others – a wakeup call to keep serving the cause of our existence, which is to serve God, through serving his people.
Tuesday, 4 May 2010
Finding new energy : poverty alleviation through technology
I was very moved by the wealth of discussion during the meeting. My relationship with Practical Action began 3 months ago when we met in Clarence House, hosted by HRH the Prince of Wales. The Prince’s Start Initiative is a new plan to introduce citizens of the UK to new energy initiatives and show where we can all save energy and become friendly user of our valuable resources for life.
For somebody like myself with no background in energy poverty, I thought poverty only hit humans in the more well documented forms - of food, housing, finance and health – and as such was eager to learn from the experts. But it soon became clear to me that in an increasingly industrialised world, a lack of access to energy – energy poverty – is increasingly a big problem for the world’s poorest.
The question which came to me was: what are the consequences of energy poverty compared with absolute poverty humans suffer from? What are the scales of both of them? If we are truly serious about eradicating poverty, then where does the need for energy sit in the big picture? The most important conclusion was that we need to transfer our technology to the poor countries, rather than export our product. Many emerging economies are based on reverse engineering and copying technologies. The new patent laws which have emerged in recent years have safeguarded the inventors, but often put a stranglehold on poor nations who have no chance to develop their industries.
Exporting our technology to poor countries might provide a short term solution, but when we leave, we take the technology with us. Only technology transfer enables poor communities to build social industry which in turn will enable them to be financially independent in the long term. Our Corporate Social Responsibility to them should not only be a financial contribution, but should be the sharing of our technology to build the industrial social fabric of their societies. This should not only be used for energy but for any field in which we can empower people by the technology we have.
There has to be positive technology transfer and skillshare, not just moving the factory to poorer countries, without safeguards or proper partnership. There must be gatekeepers: Government, civil society, local businesses, INGOs and CSR can help to ensure that technology transfer is effective and sustainable.
Our advances in technology and energy research should be used to train, empower and build capacity – all too often they instead lead to exploitation, ruin and societal disintegration.
Friday, 30 April 2010
Macedonia: A dream coming true.
‘Balkan’ is a word which is made up of two components, meaning ‘honey’ and ‘blood’. It is perhaps a fitting name for a region in which there is so much that is sweet and good, but where there has also been so much bloodshed.
During our recent conference in Skiopje, Macedonia, one Bosnian participant suggested a new name: ‘Balhan’ which would mean ‘honey’ and ‘water’. The participant was expressing a deep wish – a dream that all citizens of the Balkans need to see become a reality: a future of peace and a break with the violence of the past.
The Humanitarian Forum had to fight with that great natural/supernatural force – Iceland’s volcano – to reach skopje, capital of Macedonia. It was a question of travelling through the ashes which were preventing thousands of people from going home. Many of our members from Europe and the Middle East couldn’t make it in person, and there was a time when we had to think seriously about cancelling this long-awaited event.
But in the end, we decided to go ahead – and I am very glad we did. Fifty representatives came together, from the local Civil Society Organisations of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Serbia, Kosovo and Albania. Our ‘Balkano’ meeting seemed like a challenge to the volcano – we were saying ‘you can’t deter us!’ Some of our members still managed to get there from Turkey, Kenya and Iran – I myself took a ten hour car ride from Istanbul with a colleague in order to make the meetings.
The most important aspect of the A HOPE for the Balkans conference was the spirit of dynamic discussion between different ethnic and religious groups. Here was Natasha, a Serbian from Belgrade, leading a mixed group of Muslims from Macedonia and Albania. Jason, who represented World Vision, led another group of Bosnian, Macedonian and Kosovan participants. Amer from ICRC lead another, equally diverse group.
This spirited and dynamic dialogue was most encouraging. To see so many actors from so many areas meet the challenges facing the development of a regional civil society together – to find both collective solutions and answers to the common problems – was inspiring.
One participant told his colleague that this was the first time in his life that they had met together with so many different people. A second representative wondered that he had travelled all the way from Tehran ‘to meet his neighbours’. It seems that for us the continuous process of communication is the foundation of confidence building, which leads to operational engagement of different CSOs from different cities and countries. This communication and operational engagement will be the bedrock of humanitarian partnership – not only in the Balkans but anywhere in the world.
We want to create A HOPE for the Balkans: an Alternative Humanitarian Operational Partnership Engagement between CSOs representing different ethnic and religious groups. This is really the dream that we can make a reality – a new ‘Balhan’ region.
So let the volcano bring ashes – we’ll bring the fire of unity. Let the sky be shadowed with dark clouds – we’ll bring the light of partnership. When the wind competes with us at breakneck speed, our steady determination will win through.
Our Balkano meeting was more dynamic than the Volcano!
Monday, 26 April 2010
Breaking old habits, forging new paths in Somalia
I’ve just returned from a marathon trip. I was away for a month and in that time, I visited (amongst other places) The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Balkans, and Nairobi and Somaliland, where I spent sixteen days with a range of stakeholders, discussing the challenges, successes and obstacles for the humanitarian sector in Somalia. Participants were Muslim and non-Muslim, and we welcomed the participation of local and grass-roots organisations. Many were concerned with personal safety; all accepted that a discussion with all stakeholders - without excluding anyone – was needed in order to ensure humanitarian aid to everyone.
We were carrying a purely humanitarian message, to everyone, including governments, organisations, businesses, groups and the international community. We don’t want to be misunderstood or misread. The human need in Somalia is more than the imagination of decision makers can understand. We need to put our humanitarian spirit to the test; to balance our impartiality. If we really claim that we are the champions of the needy, we must take on board that the championship is won by delivering on people’s expectations, not by talking and doing nothing. We must give hope, and remove the conditions that breed radicalisation.
The message of humanitarianism is beyond the scope of politics, tribalism, sectarianism and ‘groupism’, not to mention the religious ‘isms’ that can abound. Since we believe the message of humanitarianism is far more universal than all of these, we have to work collectively to a sustainable solution for the humanitarian catastrophe in Somalia, as well as everywhere else.
Let us discuss serious issues. What do we mean when we talk about security and insecurity? Do we mean the security of the vulnerable community? Do we mean the security of our national field staff? Our international field staff? Do we mean the security of our organisations? Or is it the security of our funds we worry about the most? We need to be very honest about our interests when we claim to be champions of vulnerable people – to go beyond our own partialities, and put local civil society organisations at the centre of our operations. Our first responsibility is not to ourselves, but to the local community.
So we should not give up striving –however many rounds it takes – to create sustainable, ongoing security in the future.
Friday, 16 April 2010
Humanitarianism: The new colonialism?
The world has been facing numerous emergencies over the past few years. Some were manmade while the rest were natural disasters. The individual humanitarian response was overwhelming – to the point where we as international humanitarian organisations could hardly deliver the dreams and desires of our donors. The last few disasters – the tsunami; Darfur; the Asian earthquake; Yemen – proved that the international community cannot do it alone, even if we had the resources and the expertise.
We’re at a time when we have ample money to respond to disasters. But how do we allocate it? It’s my belief that we need to use some part of this money in building the local infrastructure of Civil Society Organisations in disaster areas. Five years on from the tsunami I’d like to raise a question: How much have we spent on relief, and on capacity building of local civil society, and how much has been drained and wasted because of inefficient delivery and overspending on bringing in our own experts, imported from Country A to Disaster Area B, when we could have utilized the expertise and knowledge of local organisations?
If we’re honest enough to answer such questions, I propose we change the policy of our funding with the intention of building stronger, more independent CSOs in such areas. I propose we ask our governments, institutions and INGOs to allocate 10-15% of funds to the future of local civil society in these areas.
This would be an important step, but funds alone are not enough. If our long term goal is to hand the capability for disaster response over to the local and national organisations, we need to shift our entire attitude. Rather than supporting our own organisations exclusively, our emphasis must be on partnering, training and supporting local humanitarian actors in becoming more effective, sustainable and accountable. In short: treating local actors as equals.
Changing the way we work will take time and investment. It will not happen overnight; rather it will happen over a generation. But by beginning that investment now, we will eventually build a truly global humanitarian society – one which really does ‘think globally and act locally’.
We need to be courageous - to admit that it’s impossible nowadays to respond to these terrible disasters from an international perspective alone, and to admit that it is indeed preferable to reach beneficiaries in their own communities and through their own communities. Because if we don’t work this way, we’re missing the most important players or stakeholders: namely the local civil society organisations, whom we should use as active partners from the time of planning to the process of delivering and monitoring. This could only be done when we change our mindset from a top-down, ‘colonial’ humanitarian approach to a grass roots humanitarian approach.
Our new role should be complementary to the emerging new role of stronger local civil societies. It should not replace them or exclude them. It is for us to be honest enough to step back, and instead empower those people who are already ‘on the ground’ when disaster strikes, and will continue to be there long after our operations have left.
Shall we be a colonial humanitarian movement - or a people’s humanitarian movement?
Wednesday, 3 March 2010
Yemen: Turning a coach ride into a journey
The journey turned into an operational workshop – or workshop in action. An informal, impassioned 2-day discussion – so different to such high level, high calibre, traditional, static workshops we in the humanitarian community generally favour. The fruit from such a workshop was immense – and less costly than those expensive traditional varieties, which can often be unproductive because of the top-down approach which forms them.
The result of this impromptu workshop in action was firstly confidence building between all members of HFY who participated, and secondly an implementation of THF’s organisational learning philosophy. Each small organisation was educating its sister organisations and the larger organisations managing the camps were able to educate the smaller organisations in turn. The IDPs who participate in managing the camps also educated the visiting local organisations and indeed those larger organisations managing the camps, through their involvement and feedback.
The tone of the discussion that took place between every participant was vibrant. They inspired one another, because each and every one of them was focussing on the issue of the IDPs and their welfare, and not on the agendas of their organisations, or other such issues. People didn’t feel tired as they talked; not on the coach in the early morning or the late evening; not in the field which was so hot and humid; nor even over dinner as they continued to discuss while they killed their hunger.